| 1934 – 36 |
Tom Connors |
Scottsville High School |
| 1936 – 38 |
Herb Worboys |
Honeoye Falls High School |
| 1938 – 40 |
Nelson Wood |
Spencerport High School |
| 1940 – 42 |
A.D. Oliver |
Brockport High School |
| 1942 – 44 |
George Yackel |
Pittsford High School |
| 1944 – 46 |
W. Potter |
East Rochester High School |
| 1946 – 48 |
Andy Lynch |
Fairport High School |
| 1948 – 52 |
Frank O’Donnell |
East Rochester High School |
| 1952 – 54 |
E.J. Wilson |
Spencerport High School |
| 1954 – 56 |
Cecil Luffman |
Hilton High School |
| 1956 – 58 |
Herb Bettinger |
Pittsford High School |
| 1958 – 60 |
Ed Banker |
Brockport High School |
| 1960 – 62 |
Charles Kenyon |
Rush Henrietta High School |
| 1962 – 64 |
Len Smith |
Brighton High School |
| 1964 – 66 |
Frank Demshaw |
Webster High School |
| 1966 – 68 |
Harold O’Dell |
Eastridge High School |
| 1968 – 70 |
Vern Babcock |
Irondequoit (Dake) M.S. |
| 1970 – 72 |
James Hatch |
Gates Chili High School |
| 1972 – 74 |
Paul Fauth |
Greece Arcadia High School |
| 1974 – 81 |
Wayne Adams |
Webster High School |
| 1981 – 86 |
Jim Cleveland |
Penfield High School |
| 1986 – 92 |
Don Ramsay |
Greece Arcadia High School |
| 1992 – 96 |
Jack Milner |
Brockport Middle School |
| 1996 – 98 |
Shirley Bowen |
Brighton High School |
| 1998-2000 |
Bob McEvoy |
Hilton High School |
| 2000 |
Chris Tanski |
Rush-Henrietta High School |
| 2000-2002 |
John Walker |
Webster Thomas High School |
| 2002-2021 |
Jack Milner |
Brockport M.S. – Retired |
| 2021-present |
Jack Milner |
President Emeritus |
| 2021-present |
Scott Barker |
Pittsford CSD |